Should Flooring Go Under or Around Toilet?
When it comes to bathroom renovations or new constructions, one of the common dilemmas that homeowners face is whether the flooring should go under or around the toilet. This decision may seem minor, but it can have practical and aesthetic implications. In this article, we will explore the considerations for both options to help you make an informed choice for your bathroom.
Under the Toilet: Pros and Cons
Pros:
1. Seamless Look
Placing flooring under the toilet creates a seamless and cohesive look in the bathroom. This is especially beneficial if you have chosen a luxurious or unique flooring material that you want to showcase throughout the entire space.
2. Easier Cleaning
Cleaning becomes more straightforward when the flooring extends beneath the toilet. There are no gaps or hard-to-reach areas that can collect dust or grime. This can be a significant advantage for maintaining a hygienic bathroom environment.
3. Stability and Support
Having the flooring extend under the toilet provides additional stability and support. This is particularly important for heavier fixtures like wall-mounted toilets or bidets. A solid foundation can contribute to the longevity of these fixtures.
Cons:
1. Complicated Installation
Installing flooring under the toilet can be more complex and time-consuming. It may involve more intricate cuts and adjustments to fit around the base of the fixture. This can be a challenge for DIY enthusiasts or those on a tight schedule.
2. Potential for Water Damage
If there are leaks or plumbing issues in the future, having flooring under the toilet may complicate repairs. Water can seep underneath the flooring, leading to hidden damage that may go unnoticed until it becomes a more significant problem.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
1. Easier Installation
Opting to install flooring around the toilet is generally easier and quicker. This can be a significant advantage for those looking to complete their bathroom renovation or construction project efficiently.
2. Simplified Repairs
In the event of plumbing issues or leaks, having flooring around the toilet makes it easier to access and address the problem. Repairs can be performed without the need to remove and reinstall flooring, saving both time and money.
3. Versatility in Design
Choosing to place flooring around the toilet allows for more design flexibility. You can easily change the flooring in the future without the need to work around the toilet. This flexibility can be appealing if you enjoy updating the look of your bathroom periodically.
Cons:
1. Aesthetic Disruption
One of the main drawbacks of placing flooring around the toilet is the potential for a disjointed or less cohesive appearance. This can be a concern, especially if you have chosen a high-end or unique flooring material that you want to showcase throughout the entire bathroom.
2. Cleaning Challenges
Cleaning around the base of the toilet can be more challenging than cleaning a seamless floor surface. Dust and grime may accumulate in the gaps, requiring extra effort to maintain a clean and hygienic space.
Factors to Consider
1. Type of Flooring:
The type of flooring you choose plays a crucial role in the decision-making process. Hardwood and tile floors often look more aesthetically pleasing when installed under the toilet, while vinyl or laminate flooring can be more forgiving and versatile around the fixture.
2. Bathroom Size:
In smaller bathrooms, a seamless flooring design can create the illusion of a more expansive space. On the other hand, in larger bathrooms, the impact of flooring placement may be less noticeable, giving you more flexibility in your decision.
3. Plumbing Considerations:
Consider the location of the plumbing and the potential for future repairs. If your bathroom has a history of plumbing issues, it may be more practical to install flooring around for easier access during repairs.
4. Design Preferences:
Your personal design preferences and the overall aesthetic you want to achieve in your bathroom should also influence your decision. If a cohesive and seamless look is a top priority, placing flooring under the toilet may be the preferred option.
Conclusion
In the debate over whether flooring should go under or around the toilet, there is no one-size-fits-all answer. The decision ultimately depends on a combination of practical considerations and personal preferences. Evaluate the pros and cons, weigh the factors that are most important to you, and make an informed decision that aligns with your vision for your bathroom space. Whether you choose a seamless look with flooring under or opt for versatility around the fixture, the key is to create a space that meets both functional and aesthetic needs.